Overstock Drum Chandeliers

I'm still struggling with my dining room light fixture. I'm vacillating between replacing the whole thing and trying to find a drum shade to slip over the whole thing.  I've purchased and returned 2 drum shades at this point and I'm ready to give up.  Boo!

Here are a few simple options from Overstock I might consider:

Source

Source

Source

All are right around $100.